11 July 2016

DALLAS AND THE SECOND AMENDMENT: A Response To Professor Beau Weston

As my gentle readers know, from time to time I commit “poetry”, “punery” and even “punditry. 

The problem is, you cannot be any real kind of pundit unless you read other pundits.  You have to have something to respond to.

Note: Do this only at home, kids.  

You see, in academia, the practitioners of the art of “publish or perish” take things to a high art.  But it can be dangerous when played with the pros.  Just ask Judge Robert Bork, arguably one of the most qualified nominees for the Supreme Court in the past 75 years.  He published a lot, usually in response to someone whose view of the law was 180 degrees out from his own.  That’s the way real intellectual discourse is supposed to work.  Unless you are Joe Biden (who I once, live and in person, heard suggest that perhaps, just perhaps, in the interest of national security, we might have to bring back the Court of Star Chamber (used by Charles I to enforce unpopular political and ecclesiastical policies, without cluttering up the proceedings with little niceties such as witnesses, evidence, the presence of the accused, defense counsel; it became a symbol of oppression)) or Teddy Kennedy.  Then, all that intellectual discourse becomes a weapon.  Ever wonder why no Supreme Court nominee since has let his or her judicial philosophy be examined?  But, I digress,
.
I frequently read Professor Beau Weston’s blog, Gruntled Center. He is a pundit worth reading, and responding to.  And here's the thing:  He doesn’t like guns.  He really does not like guns!  And like most liberals, because he doesn’t like something, guns in this case, he doesn’t stop there.  He doesn't want people who do like guns to have them, either.  

Now, as a conservative, I must admit that liberals do not have a monopoly on this.  An awful lot of people who detest the sin of abortion—who would never undergo the procedure themselves—are nonetheless always ready to take away from those who do favor abortion that which the Supreme Court—however erroneously—has declared to be a Constitutional right.

But, again, I digress.

Fall out!



Good.  You're back.

Fall in.

Right, Face.

For-ward, March!

Whew! 
Powerful.
Forceful.
Moving, even.

 And, I have to concede, a fair presentation of your side of the argument.  Fair, but one-sided, but that is OK: that’s why we historians and lawyers remember the Lincoln-Douglas Debates rather than The Lincoln Debate or The Douglas Debate....Fair, that is, until you wandered off into fantasy land where you get to re-write the Constitution and laws.  Fair right up to the part where you said "Everyone, that is, except the actual 'well-regulated militia,' the police force.”

Did you really think that no one would look?  No one would check, for instance, the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Kentucky ?  Your home.  The place where you teach and worship and vote.

I looked.   

Let’s start with the Kentucky Constitution:

"PREAMBLE We, the people of the Commonwealth of Kentucky, grateful to Almighty God for the civil, political and religious liberties we enjoy, and invoking the continuance of these blessings, do ordain and establish this Constitution.

BILL OF RIGHTS That the great and essential principles of liberty and free government may be recognized and established, we declare that: Text as ratified on: August 3, 1891, and revised September 28, 1891. History: Not yet amended. (sic)
 Section 1. Rights of life, liberty, worship, pursuit of safety and happiness, free speech, acquiring and protecting property, peaceable assembly, redress of grievances, bearing arms. All men are, by nature, free and equal, and have certain inherent and inalienable rights, among which may be reckoned:

First: The right of enjoying and defending their lives and liberties. …

Fifth: The right of acquiring and protecting property.

Sixth: The right of assembling together in a peaceable manner for their common good, and of applying to those invested with the power of government for redress of grievances or other proper purposes, by petition, address or remonstrance.

Seventh: The right to bear arms in defense of themselves and of the State, subject to the power of the General Assembly to enact laws to prevent persons from carrying concealed weapons. Text as ratified on: August 3, 1891, and revised September 28, 1891. History: Not yet amended. Free speech, right of, Const. 8; Religious freedom, right of, Const. 5. (sic) …
Section 219. Militia, what to consist of. The militia of the Commonwealth of Kentucky shall consist of all able-bodied male residents of the State between the ages of eighteen and forty-five years, except such persons as may be exempted by the laws of the State or of the United States. Text as ratified on: August 3, 1891, and revised September 28, 1891. History: Not yet amended. (sic) (Emphasis added.)
Section 220. General Assembly to provide for militia – Exemptions from service. The General Assembly shall provide for maintaining an organized militia, and may exempt from military service persons having conscientious scruples against bearing arms; but such persons shall pay an equivalent for such exemption. Text as ratified on: August 3, 1891, and revised September 28, 1891. History: Not yet amended. (sic)"

Note: Professor, if you are under the age of 45, you are part of Kentucky's militia (§219), but you can pay a bounty and let someone else serve if you want to (§220).  

Continue to march!  But why stop at a mere constitution. 

Ky Rev Stat "37.170  Kentucky State Defense Force -- Organization -- Reorganization.
(1) The Governor is hereby authorized to enlist, organize, maintain, equip, discipline and pay when called into active field service a volunteer state defense force other than the National Guard, which shall constitute the active militia and shall be known as the Kentucky State Defense Force, which shall consist of able-bodied citizens who are residents of the State (sic) of Kentucky between the ages of eighteen (18) and sixty-four (64) who are not active members of a reserve component of the Armed Forces of the United States.  (Emphasis added.)
 (2) Whenever the President of the United States shall call any part of the National Guard of this state into active federal service, the Governor is hereby authorized to organize the Kentucky State Defense Force under such regulations as may be promulgated by the Governor or adjutant general.

(3) The Governor shall have the power to alter, divide, annex, disband or reorganize any organization of the Kentucky State Defense Force whenever in his judgment the efficiency of the state forces will thereby be increased, and he shall have power to change the organization so as to conform to the regulations now or hereafter prescribed by the laws of the United States for the organization of the National Guard or militia. History: Amended 1984 Ky. Acts ch. 414, sec. 47, effective July 13, 1984. -- Amended 1974 Ky. Acts ch. 108, sec. 10; and ch. 386, sec. 9. -- Amended 1962 Ky. Acts ch. 48, sec. 3. -- Created 1942 Ky. Acts ch. 4, secs. 1, 4, and 8. (sic)"

Oooooo, did you see that?  The statute says 18 to 64.  Hey, I am a strict constructionist.  I'll represent you to challenge that apparent use of legislative fiat to amend the Constitution, although you may want to get someone more prominent than me.  

If I was the Commonwealth's Attorney General and I was going to defend the Statute, I would look for a really prominent Constitutional Law Professor--one nearing the end of his current job and one who thinks the legislature, or even the Governor, can just use a pencil and a telephone to change the Constitution to do the job.  But if you want me, I'm there for you.

But, you say, that’s just Kentucky.  Good point.  Let's look at federal law:

10 U.S. Code "§ 311 - Militia: composition and classes

(a)  The militia of the United States consists of all able-bodied males at least 17 years of age and, except as provided in section 313 of title 32, under 45 years of age who are, or who have made a declaration of intention to become, citizens of the United States and of female citizens of the United States who are members of the National Guard. 
(b)The classes of the militia are—

(1) the organized militia, which consists of the National Guard and the Naval Militia; and

(2) the unorganized militia, which consists of the members of the militia who are not members of the National Guard or the Naval Militia.

(Aug. 10, 1956, ch. 1041, 70A Stat. 14; Pub. L. 85–861, § 1(7), Sept. 2, 1958, 72 Stat. 1439; Pub. L. 103–160, div. A, title V, § 524(a), Nov. 30, 1993, 107 Stat. 1656.)"

(Emphasis added.)

So, let’s recap.

One: The Police are not "the" militia!  

Two: At best, the National Guard is only one small part of  the militia.

Three:  The Constitutions of many States (and arguably, the Constitution of the United States, see amend 2) recognize and actually reserve to the people the “right of revolution,” a right which can only exist so long as the State has no power to disarm its citizens. 

But, “Wait,” you say.  “Right of Revolution," you say/  "In this day and age," you say?  Nonsense,” you say!

OK. Yes. Yes. No.

Yes, in this day and age. Consider New Hampshire Constitution, art 10, adopted 1784, never amended or abolished:

 “Art 10.  Right of Revolution.   Whenever the ends of government are perverted, and public liberty manifestly endangered, and all other means of redress are ineffectual, the people may, and of right ought to reform the old, or establish a new government. The doctrine of nonresistance against arbitrary power, and oppression, is absurd, slavish, and destructive of the good and happiness of mankind.”  See, also, Pennsylvania const, art 1, §2 (Declaration of Rights) ("All power is inherent in the people, and all free governments are founded on their authority and instituted for their peace, safety and happiness. For the advancement of these ends they have at all times an inalienable and indefeasible right to alter, reform or abolish their government in such manner as they may think proper.”); Tennessee const, art 1, §2 (“That government being instituted for the common benefit, the doctrine of non-resistance against arbitrary power and oppression is absurd, slavish, and destructive of the good and happiness of mankind."); North Carolina const, Declaration of Rights, 3d (“That Government ought to be instituted for the common benefit, protection and security of the people; and that the doctrine of non-resistance against arbitrary power and oppression is absurd, slavish, and destructive to the good and happiness of mankind.”).  (Emphasis added.)

Oh, and seeing as how you started this with Texas, see, Texas const, art 1, § 2 (“All political power is inherent in the people, and all free governments are founded on their authority, and instituted for their benefit. The faith of the people of Texas stands pledged to the preservation of a republican form of government, and, subject to this limitation only, they have at all times the inalienable right to alter, reform or abolish their government in such manner as they may think expedient.”

But, I saved the best of all for last!  Constitution of the Commonwealth of Kentucky, Bill of Rights. 

 “Section 4. Power inherent in the people – Right to alter, reform, or abolish government. All power is inherent in the people, and all free governments are founded on their authority and instituted for their peace, safety, happiness and the protection of property. For the advancement of these ends, they have at all times an inalienable and indefeasible right to alter, reform or abolish their government in such manner as they may deem proper. Text as ratified on: August 3, 1891, and revised September 28, 1891. History: Not yet amended. (sic)”
That's it.  The militia is so much more than the United States armed forces, and the National Guard.  It is all of us.  And lest we forget that wonderful "manner as they may deem proper" language, that says when the oppressive government will not listen, will not redress grievances, the people, the militia, have as a last resort the right to grab their rifles and exercise their ultimate political right.  

And they can only do that if they are armed--armed with the same kind of weapons as the Government's troops, just as the men at Lexington Green and Concord Bridge were armed with the same type of weapons as the Brown Bess--the M-16 of its day.

And that, kind Sir, I submit to you, is what the Second Amendment is really all about.


10 July 2016

MCCARTY, ON RIGBY ON DECATUR

Rev Jim Rigby of Austin Texas is a prolific epigramist, frequently publishing on Face Book up to three or four of his pithy remarks daily.  He has good company: among noted modern epigramists are Mark Twain, Oscar Wilde, and Harry Truman.
I commend him to you.  He is rarely capable of being boring:  you may nod your heads to his sagacity, or your stomachs may twist and turn as he condemns everything you have spent your life defending, but he will rarely bore you. And if you read him closely, you may even find yourself saying “Hmmm.  Well, has a point!”
And that’s OK.  That’s America!  We get to freely disagree as a birthright.  Shoot, the blood of disagreeable misfits flows in our veins.  We come from those who looked at where they were and said “To heck with it.  I’ll go start my own Country where I can say and think anything I want.”
Today, he wrote
“There is a problem when our principles are no bigger than the boundaries of our nation. ‘My country right or wrong’ sounds noble until you consider the fact that, if such patriots had been born in another country, they might be zealously killing Americans by the same unthinking principle.”

To which one needs only answer الله أكبر --while slashing the throat of an American journalist.

The problem is that Rev Rigby has omitted the most important part of Commodore Decatur’s toast.  Decatur said 
“Our country! In her intercourse with foreign nations, may she always be in the right; but our country, right or wrong.”
Consider John Stuart Mill in this regard:
 “War is an ugly thing, but not the ugliest of things: the decayed and degraded state of moral and patriotic feeling which thinks that nothing is worth a war, is much worse. When a people are used as mere human instruments for firing cannon or thrusting bayonets, in the service and for the selfish purposes of a master, such war degrades a people. A war to protect other human beings against tyrannical injustice; a war to give victory to their own ideas of right and good, and which is their own war, carried on for an honest purpose by their free choice, — is often the means of their regeneration. A man who has nothing which he is willing to fight for, nothing which he cares more about than he does about his personal safety, is a miserable creature who has no chance of being free, unless made and kept so by the exertions of better men than himself. As long as justice and injustice have not terminated their ever-renewing fight for ascendancy in the affairs of mankind, human beings must be willing, when need is, to do battle for the one against the other.”
Is America perfect?  Not by a long shot, but I suggest to you that it has been closer than most countries in the past century.  It has lived up to Decatur’s aspiration, “[i]n her intercourse with foreign nations, may she always be in the right…” much more often than not.  And she has done so at huge cost of her blood and treasure.  

Those who misquote Decatur, those who are so well-defined in Mills’ fourth sentence, ignore the fact that tens of thousands, millions, are willing to become criminals, to risk horrendous obstacles, to die, just to get into America illegally.  This truth is not a condemnation of our Country.  We must be doing something right.  I suggest it is a condemnation of the rest of the world for failing to make equal sacrifices.  


08 July 2016

MEMO TO BLACK LIVES MATTER. I AGREE.


Dear Black Lives Matter,

I agree.  So, here’s what to do.

PRIME DIRECTIVE:  As parents and grandparents, as neighbors, and as citizens, we want to live our lives in peace and to see our children grow up to be safe, successful, and responsible citizens.  We have the right and responsibility to demand that they be treated with the respect they deserve, but we have a duty to ensure that they learn their responsibilities BEFORE they get the impression that their “rights”  have no limits.

RULE NUMBER 1:  Police Officers want to go home alive that night. 

RULE NUMBER 2:  Stand still.  “The wicked flee when no one pursues,…”  Proverbs 28:1a  

RULE NUMBER 3:  Do not rely on calendar age.  A 12 year old who is 5’7” and weighs 195 and points what looks like a real pistol at a police officer, doesn’t have any reason to complain if he is shot.  An Officer shot through the head by a 10 year old first offender is just as dead as if he was shot by a 35 year old career felon.   See, Rule Number 1.

FUNDAMENTAL LAW OF PHYSICS (based on Colt, Model 1911A1 pistol): From the time the trigger is pulled, the round will have traveled 20 feet in less than one-tenth of a second.  A "blink of an eye" lasts up to 4 times longer.  If the officer sees what looks like a pistol aimed at him, his only hope is to fire first. See RULE NUMBER 1.

RULE NUMBER 4:  Do not reach into your belt, or pocket, or coat until permitted to do so, and even then, very slowly.  See Rule Number 1.

RULE NUMBER 5:  Never, NEVER, NEVER try to take an officer’s side-arm.  It always ends badly if you do.

RULE NUMBER 6:  When an officer in uniform approaches you or speaks to you, “Yes, Sir” and “No, Sir” are the ONLY words that you should utter until invited to do otherwise. Politeness and courtesy will defuse most situations. Let the adrenaline dissolve.  (I am a middle class, white man.  I taught my white middle class kids the same thing.)

McCarty’s FIRST COROLLARY TO RULE NUMBER 6:  That will almost always mean that the encounter is brief and everybody gets to get on with their day unhurt.
McCarty’s SECOND COROLLARY TO RULE NUMBER 6:  The assumption by some people in 21st Century America that they have an absolute right to set all the rules, define all the rights, and ignore all their responsibilities of civility and citizenship, is what gets people killed.

RULE NUMBER 7:  If you can’t do the time, don’t do the crime.

The View From the Bleachers: Most – not all, but most-- of the Black Lives that have mattered to your relatively new movement were people who were, in some way or another, breaking the law. None of them, to date, have been police officers of color. You do your movement a disservice when you refuse to concede that. It is hard for you to garner sympathy for your cause when the only lives you champion are criminals who could have saved their lives by doing the right thing in the first place.  Just saying.
McCarty’s FIRST COROLLARY TO RULE NUMBER 7: Do what the officer tells you to do, when he tells you to do it.  Resistance is futile, usually painful, and all too frequently unintentionally fatal.
McCarty’s SECOND COROLLARY TO RULE NUMBER 7:  Making laws – defining crimes and offenses -- is the job of the legislature.  Interpreting the law is the courts.  Deciding who will make and interpret the laws is the job of every citizen at the ballot box.  What you think of the law is irrelevant out on the street.  That is why we have lawyers

CLOSING COMMENTS


The Good Right Hand Of Fellowship:  I have lived a long time. I remember an America that had segregated restrooms, lunch counters, and busses—and fire hoses, police dogs, and bombed out Sunday schools. It was unfair and un-American. We have come a long way, and still have a long way to go to get to the vision that Rev. Dr. King so eloquently prayed for. Don’t you think the journey will be a lot quicker if we walk there together?

A FEW WORDS IN SUPPORT OF DIRECTOR COMEY


This has been a hard few days for FBI Director Comey.  An honorable man, a dedicated FBI agent, and a loyal citizen, he has been placed in an excruciatingly difficult position by people who could have done their jobs instead of hiding behind him.

Background (for those who were vacationing on Jupiter this week):

For nearly a quarter of a century, no American politician or bureaucrat has held closer to the opinion that the laws that apply to most Americans do not apply to her.  As First Lady, she attempted to fire employees in the White House Travel Office in order to give that function to a company owned by personal friends.  When her actions became known, the fired employees were reinstated and her cronies lost the contract she had arranged for them.  As part of the many investigations of the ethics (or lack thereof) of the Clintons, in 2000, Independent Counsel Robert Ray issued his final report on Travelgate. He sought no charges against her, saying that while some of Clinton's statements were factually false, there was insufficient evidence that these statements were either knowingly false or that she understood that her statements led to the firings.

Her tumultuous life in the White House, I would suggest, served to make her the most paranoid national politician since Richard Nixon.  It will be interesting to see how that plays out. Certainly, it should be remembered that the legal transgressions that drove President Nixon from the White House were relatively minor—except for the cover up. One wonders whether Cheryl Mills and Huma Abedin are going to be as willing to fall on their swords for Senator Clinton as were Bob Haldeman and John Erlichman.

Horace Rumpole, Esquire, a wonderful fictional English barrister, was a master of the epigram.  One of my two favorites is: “Murder is nothing more than simple assault carried to its logical, but most unfortunate, extremes.”

The the latest contretemps, over the mishandling of classified material by then-Secretary of State Clinton, is a logical extension of “Travelgate.”  Mrs Clinton wanted something done her way.  The law stood in her path so she simply ignored the law.  And to do so, she cherry-picked legal advice.  (My other favorite Rumpolism applies here:  “Lawyers and tarts; the world’s two oldest professions.  We both aim to please.”)

And it came to pass that during sworn testimony before the House of Representatives that, contrary to all sorts of record keeping laws-implementing the Privacy Act and the Freedom of Information Act which Democrats had pushed through to ensure that “bad people” like President Nixon would have to preserve pesky records that might help, someday, tarnish or even end their presidencies.  But Mrs C is an attorney, and by some accounts, a good one. 

What if, she thought, I could keep all the records of my time as Secretary of state somewhere those pesky archivists didn’t know about.  Then, I could make sure only the history that I want people to know ever comes out.  And it worked.  Oh, some ethical employees of the State Department questioned the scheme, but the praetorians simply called them in and set things straight:  Forget that you asked and do not ever ask that question again!

Except, just as Butterfield revealed the tapes, someone revealed the “home brew” server.
Enter the FBI.

By this time, Mrs C was, at least in her own eyes, the anointed successor to President Obama.  Not going to let a little matter of law and ethics screw that up!  So, in relatively short order:

1.  The FBI began to look at those records that Mrs C had decided it ought to see. 
Not much there……… except the guy who set up the system did something unexpected.  Bryan Pagliano, an information technology specialist who helped set up Clinton's private email server, demanded immunity before he would submit to a deposition in a civil Freedom of Information Act lawsuit against Mrs C.  Now, I truly believe in innocent until proven guilty and no coerced self-incrimination, and all of that.  But nothing—NOTHING—sets a cops and a prosecutor’s heart thumping like an evidently non-descript mooch who wants immunity. 

2.  The FBI dug in.  They began to find things.  When she said that no classified material ever found its way onto her servers, she was right , except 113 classified items WERE there and another 2000 that should have been classified, weren’t.

3.  Now the President has a problem.  He is nearing the end of a failed presidency.  He wants Mrs C to have his “third term.”  But here we have the FBI finding information about Mrs C that if it was about anyone else who handles classified material would be a career-ender.  And might get that person a stylish new orange jumpsuit. 

You see, the FBI tends to take their “Fidelity, Bravery, Integrity” motto almost as seriously as West Point’s “Duty. Honor. Country.”  Or “Semper Fidelis” for Marines (a lot of whom find their way around Lunga Reservoir from The Basic School to the FBI Academy).  Or “Beat Army” for the Middies.  What’s a President to do?

Simple.  I’ve got a respected Attorney General (in comparison to her predecessor).  I’ll leave it to her and her “professional, career prosecutors.  Problem solved.

4.  But Bill and Hill, they are belts and suspenders folks.  So, as it becomes clear that the prosecutors have a whole lot of damning stuff, it becomes necessary for the Attorney General and former President Clinton to ‘just sorta happen to be in Phoenix for a couple of minutes at the same time, on the same secluded patch of isolated tarmac.  Might as well amble on over to the AG’s plane to uh,…er…swap pix of the grands, yeah, that’s it… and pass the time of day.  Just a couple of minutes. 

Well, actually nearly 40. 

“Hey Mr President.  How are the grandkids?” 

“Great.  Gorgeous.  Wanna keep on being AG in a HC presidency?  Gotta run, now.”

And here we are, the 4th of July weekend coming up, perfect time for the AG to announce that the investigation is over, the FBI report has been submitted to her, and she and her pros  have decided that there is no “there” there.  But somebody finds out. 

Somebody ALWAYS finds out.  Well not about the offer—that is something that only tens of millions of jaded Americans like me, familiar with the Clintons—could imagine.  But, you see, whether it actually happened or not, ….well, “.What difference does it make?" 

Here’s the difference.  When I was a “standards of conduct officer” as a Marine Judge Advocate, and when I was teaching it, the APPEARANCE of a conflict that did not exist was worse than a real conflict.  Sooooo, now General Lynch has to go on TV and say, there was no quid pro quo, but I’m going to follow the recommendation of the FBI.

5.  Ghost of Richard Nixon enters, stage left.  When he had a pesky problem keeping secrets from an independent prosecutor, he fired the man.  Well, actually, he ordered HIS Attorney General,Richard Kliendeinst to do it.  General Kliendienst refused.  Nixon fired him, but Deputy AG William Ruckleshaus also refused and was fired.  At that point, Kliendienst and Ruckleshaus prevailed on Solicitor-General Robert Bork, who was poised to resign, to stay on and provide moral leadership to the DOJ, at the cost of firing Cox—who was toast, anyway.

But that was 10 months or so before the missing minutes became public knowledge.  In 2016, this has to be put to rest now, before the anointing.  No time.  No time. 

So here’s the quandary facing Director Comey. 

A.  If he forces General Lynch to make the announcement, it will probably be an unleavened, salt-free, glutten-free announcement.  Got the report. Read it.  Thought about it, laughed about it, forgot about it.  “No you cannot see it!  It is an advisory opinion protected from disclosure by FOIA.  Besides, if you reeeeeeeeeally want to know what happened, you should ask the FBI, but they can’t answer, cause I’m the boss and advisory opinions and FOIA………..” (Don’t want all that "careless" and "unsophisticated" stuff out for the voters to see!!!)

B.  Make the announcement that will be the result General Lynch wants.  But show the world that you and the FBI did the job—with Fidelity, Bravery, and Integrity.

Even if the FBI had recommended charges, it was always going to be a prosecutor—either General Lynch or one of her lads and lassies who would do what the Pres and Bill and Hill wanted.  “I have reviewed the recommendations of the FBI, but it is always the prosecutors who have to make the final call…..no don’t write that down, say ‘Directory Come decided that there was no prosecutable crime."

So, Comey put all the cards on the table, showed who Senator Clinton really is, and was able to stay at the helm of the FBI to get them through this mess.

We owe him a debt of gratitude. 

Post Script:  Go back and re-read paragraph 3 of this blog entry.  Now, Consider Director Comey, this morning, before the House:  ““One of the things I have learned in this case is that the secretary may not have been as sophisticated as people would assume,. She did not even have a computer in her office, for example.  I see evidence of great carelessness, but I do not see evidence that secretary Clinton … knew she was doing something against the law.”

Sooooo, not smart enough to figure out an i-Phone, but let’s give her the nuclear launch codes anyway!

05 July 2016

WILL THE REAL CANDIDATE FOR PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES PLEASE STAND UP?


One thing I like about the internet is that it exposes me to some people who are really, really smart.  Misguided, but really smart.  I try to bring them back to the true path, but alas…..

And occasionally—occasionally—they even make me consider that, as hard as it is to imagine, maybe I’m, well, not wrong, nevah hachee, GI, but maybe an order of magnitude or two from being as right as I ought to be.

One of those really smart people is Professor William (Beau) Weston, the Van Winkle Professor of Sociology at Centre College in Danville, Kentucky. (If Centre sounds familiar, it is because it was the host to the 2000 and 2012 Vice Presidential debates.)

Now, before I go any further, I ask you to go on over to Professor Weston’s blog, Gruntled Center,  and read his 4 July 2016 piece entitled “Brexit Leaders Quit When They Realize What A Mess They Have Made” .  And remember how you got there.  You will probably want to go back from time to time.  As I said, he does his damnedest to keep me humble--which is not as hard as it sounds, because he is a really good writer, and wicked smart, to boot.  

Then c’mon back over here, because what follows is my reply and a whole lot more.

Welcome back, and awaaaaaay, we go!

I agree with Professor Weston in principle, which puts me in an awful quandary. 

First, I must say that I am not so certain that, concerning the British exit from the European Union, the alarmists are not just yelling fire in a crowded theater in which there is no fire.  Look how happy all the talking heads have been in the past two weeks.  To think that one can project the long-term results of the British exit in only ten days seems to me to be yet another example of punditry run amok. 

However, his cautionary note about the upcoming American elections is valid. Our political system is badly damaged. As an infantryman, I was tempted to say FUBAR, but that is probably excessive.  But it IS about about to leave us with no good choices to fill the office of President. 
\
I cannot imagine myself voting for Mr. Trump, but I will not vote for Senator Clinton, "wouldn't do it if you (well, not you, Prof--you probably do not have one), if someone had the apocryphal cocked and loaded pistol to my head."  And a vote for anyone else is almost assuredly a vote for the Senator.
 
I had the same emotional struggle in 1976, and made the worst mistake of my life when I voted for a man who delayed and delayed the plans to rescue our hostages because the Joint Chiefs would not give him a written promise that no Iranians would be killed or injured in the process!  

The late Professor Roger J. Champagne, my honors American History professor at Illinois State in 1964,  suggested that a major, perhaps the major, cause of the Civil War was the failure of the American political system to put real leaders into office in the 12 years prior to the election of 1860.  It is now 28 years since we have had such a President, and looking at what we have to select from this year, President Lincoln's reputation as the greatest President since George Washington is pretty safe.  Shoot, these two duds make Jimmy Carter and Warren G. Harding look attractive.   

So, where is the American political leader with the courage to stand up and say to the American people: 

We are in a mess.  I want to fix the mess. I need you to work with me.   Here's how we--you and I--are going to do it.  The first thing we say to our representatives and senators in Congress, is "Lead, follow, or get the Hell out of the way.  If you refuse to be part of the solution, then you ARE the problem."
Now, my fellow Americans, this is where your hard work comes in.  If you join with me in this Great Crusade, you are going to have to play fair with your representatives and senators.  You see, we are going to have to demand of them that they do some really scary stuff—for politicians.  What I am going to ask of you and of them is that we toss overboard a lot of the political wreckage that has littered the deck of our ship of state in the past 28 years.  And you have to let them know that if they take up the challenge, if they agree to work together to move us forward, you will resist the temptation to listen to the interest groups that have done so much damage to our nation.  That when some of the things they have to do will cause some temporary pain to you, individually and personally, you will not retaliate. 
It is time for the bankers and the union bosses and the talking heads of the media, and all the special interest groups who want to use us to test their latest wacky ideas—from unisex bathrooms to new forms of corporate welfare—to get out of our way as we start looking out for the citizens of this great nation. 
You know, it has always offended me that all the people who want you and me to sacrifice to test those ideas, especially those who claim to be interested in the poor, the uneducated or under-educated, the people with real illnesses and real disabilities, what those of us who practice the Christian faith will recognize as “the least of these, our brothers and sisters,” are commanding six and seven figure incomes.  You have to wonder--whose interests are they really furthering? 
And because I want to be your President, and the Constitutional Commander in Chief of the Armed Forces, I’ll open the bidding.  If you elect me, I will accept no salary greater than the base pay of the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.  And because the highest possible pay of our most senior military officers is actually limited to about 75 percent of the pay table maximum, that is all I will take.  And you’ll be throwing in a pretty nice house, so I won’t need the housing allowance we give our troops. 
All in all, I figure that I’ll “struggle and have to live on” less than one-third of the well over half a million dollars of your taxes that President Obama is squeaking by on.  And I’ll make sure I pay taxes on every dime of it. 
And so will anyone who serves on my cabinet.  The idea that service to our Nation doesn’t require sacrifice is going to be obsolete.   Oh, I can hear my opponent calling me unrealistic, saying that I won’t be able to get “the best and the brightest” because they can make more in the private sector.  
OK.  The best and the brightest we have had for the last 25 years don’t have a very good track record, anyway.    I guess we will just have to muddle along without them, that I’ll just have to get by on the advice of people who are in it to serve you.  Your public servants should want to serve, not profit, from serving you. 
Now, what comes next.  If you elect me, my primary domestic programs will be fixing the economy so that people can get back to work.  
To do that, in my first 100 days, I will propose a re-institution of Glass-Steagall, the act that split investment banks from what you and I think of as banks.  It is time for the gamblers to gamble with their own money, not with yours.  
In the longer term, I will propose a complete revision of our tax laws; I will propose that any federal income tax will start at dollar one, so that every citizen has a stake in ensuring that federal spending is absolutely necessary.   If we can convince you that we need twenty-five percent of every dollar you earn to run this government, that is what everyone will pay.  But if you decide that we need a nice Chevy of a government rather than a big flashy Caddy, you will have to accept the fact that a lot of the bread and circus programs that have been placed on your shoulders since 1932 may have to go.
Entitlement programs may have to be cut--real entitlement programs, the gift of a generous people to its own citizens.  NOT SOCIAL SECURITY AND NOT MEDICARE.  These are not entitlement programs!  To every citizen who was forced to pay social security and medicare taxes every working day of their lives, I promise you that not only will those programs remain in effect--at current levels--but we will act as if every Congress since the 73d Congress in 1932 had done the right thing by treating the Social Security taxes as an investment rather than a slush fund. 
And the same goes for our military retirees.  Your nation promised you certain benefits you earned by serving.  We will treat our promises as promises and our well-intentioned gifts as gifts.  And, for those who say this is unfair, that we are discriminating in favor of workers and soldiers, I will say to them what I said to a law-school classmate of mine who admired the benefits that would be mine IF I survived 20 years (or more in my case) of military service.  "You are absolutely right.  Let's go see a recruiter so you can get the same deal."  It turned out that those benefits were not really all that great and his plans for his future did not include the possibility of being killed or wounded or sent to some really unpleasant places, populated with unpleasant people who were trying to kill him. 
 Let's keep going
So, let's now take a look at foreign relations, I am all for free trade.  In the first 100 days, I will propose a Trade Reciprocity Act in which we will effectively adopt as our own the trade regulations of each of our trading partners.  If they impose discriminatory conditions to the importation of our American goods, services, products, businesses and, ultimately, workers, we will apply their very own rules and schedules to anything they want to export to us.  Or if they sell to a third party for sale to us, we will consider the third party to be the same as the originator.  What could be fairer?
Each nation's products will be welcome here, so long as they understand that if they subsidize their farmers and manufacturers so that our goods are more expensive to their own people, we will ensure that there is a tariff on their goods will make their goods as expensive as our own.  But not a penny more.  No protectionism, just fairness.
If they decide to pay their workers substandard wages, we will add back in the added cost of the fair wages we pay our own people. 
Next, when I was a young officer of Marines, there was a stretch of time when the national pastime of many Middle Easterners was kidnapping American citizens and holding them for months or even years.  A classmate of mine was serving in the Middle East on a joint US-Soviet peacekeeping force.  He told us how, one night, a couple of thugs who we had been assured by the host government  they could not identify made a mistake.  They kidnapped a Soviet citizen.  Soviet assets promptly tracked the kidnappers down, killed them, and got their citizen back.  They had to “use  up” a couple of the host government’s people to get the information they needed, but, by golly, it turned out that the host government knew exactly who the bad guys were and where they were hiding. 
Therefore, I will also announce as a new American Doctrine the following:  an attack on this Nation or any of its citizens, whether at home or abroad, by any person, entity or group that has any connection whatsoever, no matter how minor, with any foreign nation will be considered an attack on the United States by that nation and we will respond with the full power of the United States.   Get your houses in order, control the terrorists in your midst, or we will not only do it for you--we may have to level your house in the process!  Your choice.
Finally, the American frontier closed nearly 130 years ago.  As the great American historian Frederick Jackson Turner predicted, we are at a point in which, as historians, we can see that our spirit as a nation has withered and begun to devolve into a balkanized society of hyphenated Americans. 
We, as a Nation, have always had the blood of misfits flowing in our veins.  We are descended from people who said, “We can do better, we'll start a Country of our own”--and we did it!  But we have been resting on our laurels and that can only lead to the end of the American Dream. 
Accordingly, in my inaugural address, I will announce that it is the policy of the United States to put American pioneers on the planet Mars and bring them safely home by the end of the year 2030.  To do so, we will ensure that our colleges and universities have the wherewithal to provide a federally funded education in any field of endeavor that will further meeting that target. 
Understand, fellow citizens, any young American who wants to study some arcane field of study that may further general knowledge—Medieval French Literature, any of the  “Studies” degree (pick your own adjective), Sports communications-- will be free to do so, at his or her own expense. But we need engineers, and scientists, technicians, and doctors and nurses and educators and social workers and historians to bring our Nation back to where it can be a leader in creating our own experts, rather than robbing other countries of their best and brightest. 
The benefits to our Nation will be tangible.  The miniaturization that led to computers such as the i-phone, cardiac pace-makers, artificial joints and limbs that are more than a peg leg or a hook, was developed to get us to the Moon.  We got Teflon and new fire and wear resistant fabrics, and MRIs and CAT scans from the Mercury, Gemini and Apollo programs.  And we will use federal aid to elementary, secondary, and college education. to create a society that will take us to the next frontier.
Finally, I will direct the Department of Education to do two things. 
First, it will present to me, within 60 days of my inauguration, proposed model legislation to transfer its functions to the individual States.   Second, it will present to me a plan to disestablish itself within one calendar year. 
We cannot afford to spend tens of millions of dollars each year on a Department of Education that does not educate a single child.  From our earliest days, from the days of the Articles of Confederation which preceded the Constitution, education has been a State responsibility.  The Northwest Ordinance actually provided an incentive to State and local control of education.  It is time to give that back to the people who know best what is needed to properly educate their children.  Oh, the Teachers Unions and the Government Employees Unions may complain, but folks, you and I are going to take the education of our children, the citizens who will govern our great Nation when we take our well-deserved rest, out of the hands of the Union bosses and put it back into the hands of the parents and neighbors of our children.
It will not be easy.  It will require sacrifice from each of us.  A dear friend of mine once observed that “The best time to plant a tree is twenty-five years ago.  The next best time is today.”  Likewise, because no one planted the necessary trees for us 25 years ago, we have to work in the open, with no shade. We may not see the final greatness that this Great Crusade can bring because it will take time, but if we do not take the first steps together, now, who will.”
Join me, as we take the first steps into the great future that can be  ours.



04 July 2016

A THANK YOU TO THE VA FROM ONE GRATEFUL VETERAN

Hi.  My name is Mac and I have combat-related PTSD.

When I am in a store or a restaurant, I always make it a point to ask to see the manager when a clerk or server has done a good job.  You see, I know that it is human nature to complain when a service provider fails to measure up, but the over-performers never get a word of praise.  And I have noticed that when I return to a lot of these places, the standard of service across the board is often improved.

The Veterans Administration has taken some hard hits in the past year.  As a result, there has been a lot of piling on.  On Facebook, I have seen an increase in the number of Tee shirts criticizing the VA being offered for sale.  Most of them are cheap shots.  And it is a shame.

I know that there are bad actors in any outfit, and that includes the VA.  Why government employees get bonuses for just doing their jobs is a puzzle--and obviously, an over-powering temptation to the corrupt few?  But that is, I think, the exception, not the rule.

I treat at the VAMC, Coatesville, PA.  They have literally saved my life.  And I give the major part of the credit in my case to Laura Hertz, PhD.  Doctor Hertz is one of those people who give human beings a good name.  I am sure she could be making a lot more money treating the "beautiful people" suffering from the ravages of too much money, too much success, and too much public adulation!  Instead, she takes care of “those who have born the battle”, and now enjoy, in my case, “Vietnam, the gift that keeps on giving.”

Six years ago, I came within about a pound and a half of trigger pull from taking the easy way out.  I’m still not sure why that two-and-a-half hour struggle in a dark cold woods didn’t turn out the way I expected it to, but it did.  I ended up in VAMC, Coatesville, in a program with some of the best men I have known.  Together, we learned that when one man said “And I figured that I was the only one who felt that way,” 15 or 20 other guys were nodding and saying “Me, too.”  

Now, I had been treating with Dr Hertz for about a year when this happened.  The first night I was in the hospital, they came and got me because “You have a visitor.”  It was after 2100, and I could not imagine who it could be.  It was Dr Hertz, tears in her eyes, come to apologize for “failing me.”  Bless her heart—why should she have seen it in our last session 6 days earlier when I didn’t see it coming only 24 hours earlier?  The hardest part for me was to admit to her that for six months, I had been lying to her. Tough guy stuff, you know?  “Oh, I’m fine.”  “Nah, no suicide thoughts,” I would say with fingers crossed.  How did that work out, Marine?

And at the end of my in-patient treatment, I was fully prepared for her to say that she did not want to treat me anymore.  I guess that “Never leave anyone behind” thing  is taught in places other than Parris Island, San Diego, and Quantico.  

Why she can see so deeply into things that are still cloudy to me I don’t know, but she does. Understand me, she can be tough as nails when she needs to be, and because she has earned our respect, she can have the hard Dutch Uncle talks with us when necessary.  Petite little fireball she may be, but she could teach some Gunnery Sergeants a trick or two about presence and bearing.   For the guys and gals in our group, she is as accepted as any vet.  She knows things about me that no one on earth knows—and cares anyway.  I guess that’s it: she cares anyway.

So…..

First, to the youngest batch of vets I say, “If the dreams, or the anger, or the numbness, or the lack of trust shows up, get help.  Take care of it now, with folks who understand.  I assure you that it will be better to try now than to wait for 40 years as I did.  It is like a boil, left untreated.  The putrefaction is going to come out anyway, but if you wait, it is going to be some REALLY nasty stuff!”

Second, the vets I know at the VA are warriors who have, in many cases, been fighting the good fight for nearly half a century.  There is no shame in asking for help. 

Finally, to the rest of you—your Department of Veterans Affairs is doing a pretty damned good job. If you want to complain, please be specific.  The treatment professionals—the Nurses who help a sobbing vet way from the commode where he has just thrown up because the memories of shipmates lost got too bad, the psychologists who spend multiple sessions getting to the root of one terrible memory, the psychiatrists who make sure meds are the right ones in the right amounts—they are doing a great job. 

If there is any legitimate complaint, it is this.  After the Arizona fiasco, Coatesville suddenly had all sorts of construction of new offices where waiting rooms had been.  Sadly, the offices seem to be occupied by new bureaucrats monitoring other bureaucrats who monitor….well, you get my drift.

Tell your Congresscritters, your Senators, that they should ignore the unions and the make-works and just get more docs and nurses in place and then get out of their way. And shoot the accountants—the idea that you can tell someone that it should only take 2.36458791 visits to peel away a 40 year old onion of memories is, well, stupid.  But I digress….

Instead send us just one more Laura Hertz: she will amaze you, saving lives and earning the undying respect and gratitude of the vets she saves!

   

03 July 2016

THE FIRST PRAYER FOR OUR NATIONAL LEADERS

I have heard it said by those who misread the First Amendment as a Constitutionally-mandated "freedom from religion"--something it never has been--that we as a people should be "protected"  from the "modern imposition" of religion through prayer at the opening of each day's sessions of the House and the Senate.  This is, of course, utter nonsense in so many different and distinct ways, but one of the most cynical is the assertion that the Founding Fathers had no interest in religion in general or the Christian faith in particular.
In fact, the practice of opening legislative deliberations with prayer predates our existence as free and independent States by nearly two years.  The record shows that when the first representatives to the First Continental Congress met for the first time, the question arose as to what should be their first action. 
John Adams, Esquire, of Massachusetts (later first Vice President of the United States and second President) proposed that before anything else, the Congress should be opened with prayer.  Accordingly, Rev Jacob Duche, Rector of Christ Church, Philadelphia was summoned to offer opening prayer.  After reading Psalm 35, he offered the following prayer--which still resonates and is equally applicable to our current National leaders.
"O Lord our Heavenly Father, high and mighty King of kings, and Lord of lords, who dost from thy throne behold all the dwellers on earth and reignest with power supreme and uncontrolled over all the Kingdoms, Empires and Governments; look down in mercy, we beseech Thee, on these our American States, who have fled to Thee from the rod of the oppressor and thrown themselves on Thy gracious protection, desiring to be henceforth dependent only on Thee. To Thee have they appealed for the righteousness of their cause; to Thee do they now look up for that countenance and support, which Thou alone canst give. Take them, therefore, Heavenly Father, under Thy nurturing care; give them wisdom in Council and valor in the field; defeat the malicious designs of our cruel adversaries; convince them of the unrighteousness of their Cause and if they persist in their sanguinary purposes, of own unerring justice, sounding in their hearts, constrain them to drop the weapons of war from their unnerved hands in the day of battle!
Be Thou present, O God of wisdom, and direct the councils of this honorable assembly; enable them to settle things on the best and surest foundation. That the scene of blood may be speedily closed; that order, harmony and peace may be effectually restored, and truth and justice, religion and piety, prevail and flourish amongst the people. Preserve the health of their bodies and vigor of their minds; shower down on them and the millions they here represent, such temporal blessings as Thou seest expedient for them in this world and crown them with everlasting glory in the world to come. All this we ask in the name and through the merits of Jesus Christ, Thy Son and our Savior.
Amen.
Reverend Jacob Duché
Rector of Christ Church of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
September 7, 1774, 9 o’clock a.m.

02 July 2016

A PRAYER ON THE SUNDAY BEFORE INDEPENDENCE DAY

Brothers and sisters: two hundred forty years ago, just down the road in Philadelphia, the foundational American document declared

“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.”

The Declaration closed, as it had opened, by placing the fate of the nation into the hands of God, declaring
“We, therefore, the representatives of the united States of America, in general congress, assembled, appealing to the Supreme Judge of the world for the rectitude of our intentions, do, in the name, and by authority of the good people of these colonies, solemnly publish and declare, that these united colonies are, and of right ought to be free and independent states; … and for the support of this declaration, with a firm reliance on the protection of divine providence, we mutually pledge to each other our lives, our fortunes and our sacred honor.”

As we meet to worship our Creator today, it is right and proper that we turn to Him with prayers of thanksgiving, of confession, and of invocation.

Let us pray.

Father, as we assemble in Your house, a house whose walls shade the final earthly resting places of a score of men who gained our independence with physical sacrifice, led by the very Shepherd you sent to them for that purpose, we give you thanks.

We thank you for

A fertile land—a land of still waters and green pastures.
A land of plenty—in which the table you have set for us groans with goodness and nourishment for our bodies from the fertile soil you entrusted to us.
For a land of opportunity for all and not just a few.
For a noble land that seeks, however imperfectly, to be worthy of You, sacrificing over and over again blood and treasure so that other lands, less fortunate, might have the unalienable rights, of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness, and especially, the right to worship you openly and without fear

For all these—and more—for the many blessings You have showered on us and the protections You have afforded us, we give You thanks and praise. 

But Father, we also know that we, individually and as a nation, have not lived up to the standard You expect of us.  We have not always been a nation in which all men are received as equal, having had to pay a blood sacrifice to free those of your children whom we had treated as property rather than as brothers and sisters. 

We are a land in which many children—through no fault of their-- own go to bed hungry at night.

We are a land that, mainly for the sake of convenience, allows three-quarters of a million babies to be aborted every year without even acknowledging them in our official records and reports as deaths.

We are a land which has allowed—even encouraged--the duties of parenthood to be casually tossed aside and placed into the cold hearts and hands of a social and educational bureaucracies designed to hide You or any mention of You from those very dear little ones.

We are a land in which we have removed You from the public arena, allowing worship of You and adherence to Your dictates to be treated as if they are something shameful, something to be scorned and hidden, rather than the expected norm. 

We have lacked the courage to stand up to those who hate You and to bring the good news of Your Son to people who hunger and thirst for him without knowing for whom or what it is they crave -- because we have failed Him and His Great Commission to us.

For all these failings, whether overt or latent, for all these sins of commission and omission—and so many more-- we ask Your forgiveness. 

Finally, Father, having acknowledged our sin, our weakness, our greed –we now pray that You will bring a new great awakening to this land.  Lead us back onto the paths of righteousness for Your name’s sake.  Open our hearts, open our minds, refresh our spirits, that we may eagerly take up the cross of your Son. 

Send us, Father, to Judea, and Samaria, and to the ends of the earth—across seas and mountains and deserts -- to share the good news of Jesus Christ and Him crucified with those who do not know Him.  

But even more Father, send us to the end of the block, send us 50 feet to our next door neighbors, on the same mission.  Use us, Father, as your instruments to restore this nation, use us to witness strongly and with courage to our neighborhoods and communities just what it means to follow your Son. 

Oh dear heavenly Father, we thank you for Your goodness, we crave Your forgiveness for our sin, and we earnestly desire that You use us to serve You and your blessed Son, Jesus Christ, in whose strong and glorious name we pray.  

And the people of God say Amen and Amen.